valley ranch
Garden Master
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2014
- Messages
- 5,742
- Reaction score
- 5,733
- Points
- 367
There are plenty of American cheese makers that produce wonderful "proper" Parmesan, and have been doing so for decades. The USA does recognize European legal protections but not after the fact. The Italians, and others, messed up and didn't trademark their product names until after companies all over the world "copied" those cheeses. Kraft was making Parm long before the Italians realized that they might want to protect their names. Gouda and Gruyere are 2 other great examples. In fact, the highest ranked competition Gouda in the world comes from Canada, not Europe, so she obviously does a pretty good job of not only replicating it but producing it better than the originals. Take the name protection one logical step further. If the guy who made the very first Parm had protected the name, then nobody, not even other Italians, could make that cheese. There would be one (very rich) company in the world allowed to make "proper" Parm. The designation Parmiggiano Reggiano is nothing more than regular Parm that is recognized as being from a particular area of Italy. It's a marketing point.
How about Baby Swiss, invented by a guy in Ohio. If he had protected that name from the beginning, only he could make something called Baby Swiss. The same single source logic could be applied to every cheese ever made.
Or look at the case of English Stilton. Modern laws governing the name of Stilton prescribe that it be made with pasteurized milk, even though it was made with raw milk for hundreds of years. Ironically, now the only raw milk producer is relegated to using the name Stichelton. HUGE IRONY.
How about Baby Swiss, invented by a guy in Ohio. If he had protected that name from the beginning, only he could make something called Baby Swiss. The same single source logic could be applied to every cheese ever made.
Or look at the case of English Stilton. Modern laws governing the name of Stilton prescribe that it be made with pasteurized milk, even though it was made with raw milk for hundreds of years. Ironically, now the only raw milk producer is relegated to using the name Stichelton. HUGE IRONY.