Pulsegleaner
Garden Master
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2014
- Messages
- 3,549
- Reaction score
- 6,977
- Points
- 306
- Location
- Lower Hudson Valley, New York
I will remind you that that is only my THEORY based on what I have seen, I have no direct proof.Mr. Brown is a tomato I've always wanted to try; I tried Brown Berry and the colour was incredible. 'The Blob' - what a name! That is interesting how tomatoes evolved in size through flowers merging. It makes me think of some of the 'older' tomatoes I've grown, like the Purple Calabash you mention which is small and highly ruffled. The historical portraits of 'beefsteak' tomatoes all show rather ruffled, 'lumpy' fruit. The Italian Costoluto is ruffled, the African one I tried called Korrogo du Senegal was a 'beefsteak cherry' also ruffled, and one from Afghanistan called Rumi Banjan was a beefsteak cherry too, in yellow. I think these are all rather old varieties. So it makes me wonder if, as the size of tomatoes increased, this ruffle quality was part of the progression away from small cherry types. And then from there the movement was to breed the 'lumps' out of the bigger ad bigger tomatoes, selecting for smoothness. Yes, there is a Aunt Ruby's German Green cherry, I've been tempted to try it but the vendor listed in the description 'must be picked just before maturity for best taste' which suggests to me they might be bland?
I suppose a good way to check is to compare where the ruffles are on the outside of the tomato when it is whole to where the locules are when you cut it in half. The one problem I am seeing with the ruffled to beefsteak idea is that there are plenty of tomatoes that are ruffled and still more or less round in cross section. So the ruffles would have had to still be there AFTER the flowers totally integrated, and then gotten bred out.
I'm not the person to ask about ARGG, as it is one of the few green when ripe tomatoes I DON'T like (with it's high "meat" to gel ratio, I find it a little too firm and mealy for most of the uses I put my tomatoes to, where I want a decent amount of juice (I'm quite comfortable with my Bruschetta, Horiatiki, and Insalata Caprese being rather wet and sloppy, and needing bread to sop up all the juice.)
If you do want to try it, I think Ben's Tomatofest still carries Mr. Brown.