A Seed Saver's Garden

heirloomgal

Garden Addicted
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
4,305
Reaction score
13,828
Points
255
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
speaking of stunted plants that are persisting, i still have the FPJ plants blooming and trying to give me some seeds. none of the pods i've picked so far has had a viable bean in them. :( i hope they'll keep going but my guess is that this will be the last year i grow them unless i get really lucky next year somehow with them. i may not have any more FPJ seeds at all that will grow. we'll see... :)
Do you think it's too hot in your location? Why do you think you haven't had much luck?
 

flowerbug

Garden Master
Joined
Oct 15, 2017
Messages
17,115
Reaction score
27,062
Points
427
Location
mid-Michigan, USoA
Do you think it's too hot in your location? Why do you think you haven't had much luck?

a combination of heat, drought, full sun and heavy soil types where planted. i've been trying them in different gardens and only one really does even partly good with them has sandier soil. any time i've put them in heavier soil gardens they languish and pout like spoiled children who want their pudding and aren't getting it.

this late spring i planted them early hoping to get some cooler weather for them before the heat, but we had a very hot early summer so that plan was completely off-kilter from the get-go. the plants sprouted, but then sat there and hardly grew for six weeks. i was picking beans from 2ft tall Purple Dove that were planted later than the FPJs while the FPJs were just starting to get big enough to bloom. none of those pods filled properly. a bunch of empty pods or beans that were partly formed and then aborted. the neighboring peas, and PD beans just cruised along like nothing was much of a bother to them in comparison.

while i love the color and shape they're just not working here. i'll still plant whatever i can grow of them, but i'm also planting a lot more other more hardy beans instead that are more suited towards our conditions.

better garden soils and some shade and cooler overall temperatures and regular moisture seem to be what they're calling for. almost none of that exists here. the moisture i did keep up with. peas wouldn't have done very well had i neglected their watering. i had a really nice pea crop hanging on those plants until the chippies ate most of them.
 

digitS'

Garden Master
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Messages
26,896
Reaction score
33,159
Points
457
Location
border, ID/WA(!)
FPJ? Can one of you ID?

HeirloomGal, Jacob's Cattle (& Soldier) were varieties that I grew for several years. I think that I was inspired by @Bluejay77 showing up on TEG 7 or 8 years ago. I did some reading about John Withee's Wanigan experience and what inspired him as a child. I didn't know that there was a Gold variety.

Anyway, those two were tasty and very productive in my garden.

Steve
 

heirloomgal

Garden Addicted
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
4,305
Reaction score
13,828
Points
255
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
FPJ? Can one of you ID?

HeirloomGal, Jacob's Cattle (& Soldier) were varieties that I grew for several years. I think that I was inspired by @Bluejay77 showing up on TEG 7 or 8 years ago. I did some reading about John Withee's Wanigan experience and what inspired him as a child. I didn't know that there was a Gold variety.

Anyway, those two were tasty and very productive in my garden.

Steve
I posted a picture of them not too long ago on LEBN. #1082 I think it said.
 

heirloomgal

Garden Addicted
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
4,305
Reaction score
13,828
Points
255
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
Starting to have some real rootin' tootin' FUN with my dried bean harvesting!!!
I am just LOVING my network bean 'King's Knight'! What a gorgeous dry bean, and it was totally weather resilient, held it's pods nice and high up off the ground (a trait I really appreciate) and it stayed quite upright compared to some others. The pod set was good and they are drying down quite nicely. @Bluejay77 is the photo of the bean on your website of a fresh bean? That is the only thing I'm wondering about this bean, they all look a bit different than that photo. These ones have more whitish speckling on the dark blackish/bluish seeds. There are a few totally dark ones, but nearly all of them are more speckled.

'Amish Gnuttle', crazy production for 4 plants. I can see why this may have been popular with settlers. If surplus food is what one seeks, this bean is it.

After several days, I finally finished shelling almost all the dried peas; all it took was Crocodile Dundee 1 & 2, and Back to the Future 3. 😂 Shelling requires only hands, not so much the eyes I've discovered.

Have another big round of squeezing tomatoes tomorrow, my last big one for this year. It'll only be a trickle after that, phewf. Then more beans, beans, beans! So thrilled that the 'Piekny Jas' beans will be a success, I see a lot of bulging pods out there now! (Although I'd like to rename that bean 'T-Bone' based on the size of them 😄)

So, 'Hopi' 'Mitla Black' and 'Nicaraguan Black Turtle' are all very nice, very productive though tiny beans. They are also nearly impossible to tell apart!
Same goes for 'Shirolustuca Kovina' and 'Fruhe Goldbohne' - identical in every way as far as I can tell. 'Giele Waldbeantsje' might be their twin too, but it is taking them SO LONG to mature I may never know. Man, I can't believe how late this bush bean is. That aspect of them is certainly different.😩

Such a great time to enjoy the garden!
 

Blue-Jay

Garden Master
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
3,368
Reaction score
10,602
Points
333
Location
Woodstock, Illinois Zone 5
I am just LOVING my network bean 'King's Knight'! What a gorgeous dry bean, and it was totally weather resilient, held it's pods nice and high up off the ground (a trait I really appreciate) and it stayed quite upright compared to some others. The pod set was good and they are drying down quite nicely. @Bluejay77 is the photo of the bean on your website of a fresh bean? That is the only thing I'm wondering about this bean, they all look a bit different than that photo.

The photo of Kings Knight on my website was seed grown that season the photo was taken, but probably dried for about two months. It was not old seed. It just might be the difference in the soil I grew them in at the time and your soil. The place where I grew them I don't grow anything there anymore so it might be interesting to try that bean in the places where I grow beans now.
 

heirloomgal

Garden Addicted
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
4,305
Reaction score
13,828
Points
255
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
Well, there is no frost in the foreseeable future yet, but I can really feel fall setting in. The temperatures have fallen to the low 20's now and nights hover around 10 degrees, 7 tonight. It's too cold to sleep with the windows open. There is a cool crispness in the air that wasn't present just days ago. It is amazing how quickly a season can go by; there is still plenty to do in the garden but we've turned a corner. Pole beans are just starting to dry, potatoes aren't dug up yet, lots of peppers need harvesting asap. I've started cutting the pumpkins off the vines. Somehow this captured the contemplative sense I had tonight while pulling up bush bean plants to hang dry indoors, a goodbye summer feeling-
20210831_162734.jpg


I'll miss you fresh green tomatoes! This is the last ripe one on the vines.
20210831_163327.jpg


I honoured his memory in tomato & feta salad 😊
20210831_162530.jpg


Collected several dried pods from this trellis now, the leaves are just starting to yellow. This was a garden construction I've wanted for a long time. It was so nice to see the hummingbirds fly from flower to flower. It covered much more thickly than I thought it would, I'll be growing runner beans on here for awhile I think. Not sure if there is any reason for it, but the north facing side grew more than the other, by quite a bit.
20210831_162809.jpg


Dainty little flower of the 'Helios Yellow' radishes I planted. Patiently awaiting seed. I'm not a radish fan (unless they are steamed) but these plants put in with the carrots did a marvelous job of keeping the carrot rust fly away. I haven't seen a trace of them. If it wasn't for the radishes I wouldn't be able to grow carrots. My previous radish seeds were not very good quality, so I'm hoping to do better this year.
20210831_163053.jpg


Another one I'm waiting for, dill. I could let it re-seed here, but the location won't be where I want it next year, so into a packet it will go.
20210825_160024.jpg


I think I just might make it with the soybeans! Pods are not too far off from maturity. Fingers crossed.
20210831_162902.jpg


My lone bean tower is in dire straits...tried, but mission impossible to get it back up. Very broken & really lots of 1,500 year old cave beans on it (I hope they finish! 😨) I accidentally created a giant bean wind sail. Turns out growing beans 15ft in the air is not the best idea.
20210831_163015.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top