Smart Red
Garden Master
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2012
- Messages
- 11,303
- Reaction score
- 7,405
- Points
- 417
- Location
- South-est, central-est Wisconsin
Did some online research into "Needling" as Dew described it. Here it sounds pretty good, but does lend itself to the pain Dew experienced. Perhaps understanding the procedure would make it easier to tolerate.
Here is another viewpoint to "Needling". Consider the source. I recognize the difference between acupuncture and needling. All the disparaging remarks sound a lot like sour grapes.
Acupunture is an old technique with specific points. For example the needle may be inserted into a point on the back with the intent of effecting stomach or bowel function or near the ear to effect a cure for over-eating. Needling is done to the damaged tissue directly and results were tested with scientific research.
Still, I would expect the therapist to have certification (licensed training) showing before using that technique. It isn't for me to say either, both, or neither of the methods are useful or effective; only that they are available and they are different for a reason.
Finally, some research on the Needling procedure by the Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy.
Do what you have to do, @dewdropsinwv. I would try it -- you did. The idea of no pain no gain is a pile of horse phooey. I am with Carol in the use of TENS, (realizing of course that neither of us is a doctor). As I understand the two choices, needling is used to find and unlock damaged muscle bundles while TENS is used to depress pain signals and speed recovery of the sore tissue.
I love this place. Even when it is not gardening, we learn something new here. Thank you, Dew, for the opportunity to find out about Needling. I sure hope and pray you find the best medical professionals to get you back feeling your pre-accident self asap. Notice I didn't wish you good luck. We don't want to rely on luck when dealing with your health!
Here is another viewpoint to "Needling". Consider the source. I recognize the difference between acupuncture and needling. All the disparaging remarks sound a lot like sour grapes.
Acupunture is an old technique with specific points. For example the needle may be inserted into a point on the back with the intent of effecting stomach or bowel function or near the ear to effect a cure for over-eating. Needling is done to the damaged tissue directly and results were tested with scientific research.
Still, I would expect the therapist to have certification (licensed training) showing before using that technique. It isn't for me to say either, both, or neither of the methods are useful or effective; only that they are available and they are different for a reason.
Finally, some research on the Needling procedure by the Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy.
Do what you have to do, @dewdropsinwv. I would try it -- you did. The idea of no pain no gain is a pile of horse phooey. I am with Carol in the use of TENS, (realizing of course that neither of us is a doctor). As I understand the two choices, needling is used to find and unlock damaged muscle bundles while TENS is used to depress pain signals and speed recovery of the sore tissue.
I love this place. Even when it is not gardening, we learn something new here. Thank you, Dew, for the opportunity to find out about Needling. I sure hope and pray you find the best medical professionals to get you back feeling your pre-accident self asap. Notice I didn't wish you good luck. We don't want to rely on luck when dealing with your health!
