Experiments, observations, and lessons learned

digitS'

Garden Master
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Messages
26,590
Reaction score
31,959
Points
457
Location
border, ID/WA(!)
It surprises me every year.


IMG_0901.jpeg
The first day for the tomato seedlings to venture out to the South Window :). There are about 7 seeds of each of these 6 varieties. Two more are in the cookie box with the eggplant. It is the same story there.

The seedlings of 2 varieties from purchased seed are yet to emerge. The one closest to the camera in the "tomatoes only" box is the purchased seed there – Yellow Jelly Beans hybrid. The other with the eggplant is heirloom, Kellogg's Breakfast. Neither has a single sprout appearing.

Both are a little old – the Kellogg's Breakfast are from 2020; the Jelly Beans are probably from the same year, (that dang Seeds n Such doesn't put dates on their packets). However, the other varieties are also likely from old seed. Every One of those 6 are from Saved Seed and Every One of those has most or all seed sprouted and growing.

I follow a very simple approach to saving tomato and pepper seed. The most serious part of the program is to start seed that is no more than 5 years old. Older and it sprouts but will likely be slower and, starting in these "community containers" means that there is competition for space and sunlight. It is not good if some plants are a week or more behind the others in getting a start.

Anyway, see how competitive the seedsaver (me ;)) is performing against the seed companies? Surprising to me! Try seed saving if you aren't already ;).

Steve
 

heirloomgal

Garden Addicted
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
4,165
Reaction score
13,367
Points
255
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
I think there are layers to unpack in a neat observation such as this. Some of those layers, if not most, will likely remain ellusive but it's fun to speculate. I have great success with home saved seeds, with some species being extra demonstrative of the benefit. Peas, for example. The results from a row of home saved seed from the 2nd year versus the bought seeds from the 1st year planting, even if they weren't that old to begin with, can be mindboggling. I've had 5X the seeds by year 2.

Someone on the bean forum once mentioned that first year, newly received beans can be recalcitrant to grow well, and will produce a below average amount of seeds, but the seeds collected and regrown in the same garden from that original planting do remarkably better the following year.

Is it all attributable to old age? I'm not sure, but I'm inclined to believe not. Some watermelon histories tell of farmers whose practice was to not plant seeds less than 10 years old. And they carried the seeds around in a pouch for a time before planting the year they were to be grown, the belief being it activated some principle in the seed. They believed older seed, in some instances, was better. Were they on to something? Probably many secrets lurk in the being-ness of those seeds! Recently I have had the itch to plant the rest of my pepper seeds, but I'm taking the waxing of the moon into consideration this year, and now the new moon. Lunar cycles and seeds seem to have a relationship too, a factor the older generations seem to have taken into consideration.
 

digitS'

Garden Master
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Messages
26,590
Reaction score
31,959
Points
457
Location
border, ID/WA(!)
The seedlings of 2 varieties from purchased seed are yet to emerge. ... Yellow Jelly Beans hybrid. ... heirloom, Kellogg's Breakfast
Only Today, the Kellogg's Breakfast showed up and only 1 of the 7 seeds, so far. This is 10 days later.

The Yellow Jelly Beans have been up and growing awhile but, they had a difficult experience this afternoon. Lined up with others that made a quicker start, I decided that it would be best to move everything out of the cookie box. So, the little guys went into the ponies with their bigger, more mature companions. They should be fine but there were a couple that only had cotyledons and I decided that the chances were not good enough to bother moving them to 4-.packs.

Fortunately, I guess, the Kellogg's Breakfast are not in a crowd and can be left for a few more weeks without being disturbed. (The limited number of plants in 2024 compared to the days of plant sales at the farmers' market causes me to look around after the transplanting and think, "Am I done? Really?! That's it?" Well, it makes them individually more valued ;).)

Saving seed and running against purchased seed every year – Worth the Try.

Steve
 
Top