It bears a little resemblance to the honey mushroom, but I don't think the gills look right and the stems look too shiny. (Those also have a poisonous look-a-like.) I have a book, Mushrooms of West Virginia and the Central Appalachains that is a really great guide. They may have a version for your area. Or sometimes your county ag. extension agency or local college will have a mycologist on staff who can help you. For my area, there are only 4 varieties of edible mushrooms that are easily identifiable out of 1000's.
You could try getting a spore print too, that would help. Put a cap, gills down, on a piece of black paper and one on white paper and cover each with a glass and leave it for 12-24 hours. See which color the spores show up.
There's only a handful of mushrooms that will kill you. But there is maybe 95% of them will make you sick to your stomach, so it's very important not to eat one that hasn't been positively identified. So glad you didn't! It doesn't look like any oyster mushroom that I've ever found (the stalks are very short on them and fan out into the cap.)
If you do get a positive ID on a mushroom, particularly by someone who regularly hunts them or is an expert, you still have to be careful. Even the edible ones can cause gastric distress if not thoroughly cooked and some people may have sensitivities to them even though they are otherwise safe. Any first time trying a new edible mushroom, it's wise to only eat a little bit and see how it sits with you. If that goes well, you can try a little bit larger portion next time.
Not to sound like a mother hen, but I just wanted to make sure you and others know to take care with wild mushrooms.
I have no idea and am of no help! I did however, get lost on one of those mushroom sites and have it EXTREMELY interesting to say the least. Thanks for the links!