Beekissed
Garden Master
I am voting both are hens. I am no expert, but interested in chickens and had a couple once, and worked on a chicken farm. Lol. I found a picture of an Easter Egger hen. At least the picture says it was a hen. View attachment 31498
Most definitely a hemale.
I think the jury is still out on that EE...their traits are VERY muddy, so it could be a very blokey lookin' pullet. Most of us are used to a dual purpose breed in our yards, so when we see a Mediterranean looking breed there, they always look like they are standing too tall, the tail looks too male, they look a little light in the breast, etc.
I wouldn't get disappointed just yet.
Here's an EE pullet with a slightly sickle looking tail and a bit of an upright stance as well, though she looks a little older and heavier in the breast than your white, Miss Mary...